AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

🔍 Read the full analysis: The AI Debate Around Graduate Jobs: What Evidence Can Tell Us on ThorstenMeyerAI.com

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

TL;DR

UK and Australian data show falling job adverts in occupations with greater exposure to AI, including some roles often held by graduates. The evidence does not establish AI as the cause: economic conditions and other changes may also explain weaker hiring, and Australia’s graduate-posting decline began before widespread AI adoption.

UK and Australian job-ad data show weaker hiring in occupations more exposed to AI, including customer service and administrative work that can provide entry-level routes into employment. But the evidence reviewed by ThorstenMeyerAI.com does not establish that AI caused the declines; economic slowdowns, pandemic-era hiring and labour costs are among the competing explanations.

A Bank of England staff analysis by Haley Schlicht compared UK online adverts with occupations’ estimated exposure to AI. The analysis found adverts fell 15% in the most exposed third of occupations, compared with 10% in the middle third and 6% in the least exposed third. Customer service adverts declined 23% and administrative adverts 22% over the period examined. These are changes in job adverts, not a count of jobs lost or proof that employers replaced workers with AI.

The analysis, published on the Bank’s Bank Underground blog in August, used occupational exposure scores and Office for National Statistics online advert data. Schlicht cautioned that “confident attribution remains premature,” citing factors including pandemic over-hiring, a cyclical slowdown, remote work and higher labour costs. Separately, the ONS estimated 691,000 UK vacancies in July to September 2026, 21,000 fewer than in the previous quarter. It said smaller firms may be holding back recruitment because of higher labour costs.

Australian job-posting figures point in a similar direction but complicate a direct AI explanation. The source article reports that graduate postings fell almost 15% in 2025 and fell further in AI-exposed jobs. It also says the decline began in 2023, before wide AI adoption, while apprenticeships—described as barely exposed to AI—fell 46% from their peak, citing Indeed. These figures indicate pressure on early-career opportunities, but do not isolate its cause.

At a glance
reportWhen: Published November 17, 2026; the cited…
The developmentA review of central bank research and official and job-ad data finds weaker hiring in AI-exposed occupations, while leaving the cause of the decline unresolved.

AI and the entry level · explainer

From career pyramid to diamond

Why the first rung of the ladder is where AI could show up first, and why the cause is not settled yet.

A workforce by level (schematic)

Senior Junior AI takes tasks

Pyramid: many juniors at the basedoing scheduling, correspondence and routine information processing UK job adverts: −15% vs −6%in the most vs the least AI-exposed third of occupations Diamond: hollow at the base“centred on experienced staff”

How the squeeze could work

  1. First jobsRoutine tasks: scheduling, correspondence, routine information processingthe base of the pyramid
  2. AI steps inSenior workers can do more of the work that once formed the bedrock of junior hiringBank Underground
  3. Fewer advertsUK online job adverts fell 15% in the most AI-exposed third, 6% in the leastBank Underground, ONS data
  4. DiamondThe pyramid may turn into a diamond, hollow at the baseBank Underground
  5. Not settledPandemic over-hiring, the business cycle, remote work and labour costs hit at the same time“confident attribution remains premature”
The open question for employers: if the base hollows out, who becomes the experienced staff of the next decade?

Source: Haley Schlicht, Bank of England, Bank Underground blog, Aug 6, 2026 (staff view, not necessarily the Bank’s), based on ONS online job adverts through early 2026; the pyramid-to-diamond idea is from research the post cites. The blocks are a schematic, not data. The question in the orange box is ours.

Graphic: Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI

The Risk to Graduate Entry Routes

When firms advertise fewer junior roles, graduates may face a tighter path into work even if AI is not the reason those roles have declined. Customer service and administrative jobs often involve routine information processing, scheduling and correspondence, tasks that can overlap with AI capabilities. The available figures identify an association between exposure and falling adverts, not a confirmed pattern of automation-driven job losses.

The longer-term concern is about how workers gain experience. If employers reduce junior hiring, businesses could have fewer employees developing the judgement and practical knowledge needed for more senior roles later. That is a potential consequence, not an outcome established by the cited data. For universities, the debate also concerns whether graduates can evaluate AI-generated work, spot errors and improve results rather than simply operate a tool.

Products Worth Considering

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Two Warnings, Uneven Evidence

The debate intensified with two reports in the same week. On November 15, Armin D Ashenberg, a senior lecturer in law and emerging technologies at Western Sydney University, argued in The Conversation that AI could change the graduate job market. He wrote that employers may have little economic reason to involve a worker who cannot improve the quality or efficiency of AI output. This is an expert argument about possible incentives, not evidence that employers have already broadly removed graduate roles.

On November 13, The Telegraph reported that the head of the UK Office for Budget Responsibility had warned of “very painful” job losses from AI. ThorstenMeyerAI.com said the article was behind a paywall, that it had not reviewed the story itself, and that it found no OBR or parliamentary record of the remarks or another outlet quoting them directly. The warning should therefore be treated as a report by The Telegraph, not as a statement independently confirmed in the material reviewed.

The OBR’s October 2026 Economic and fiscal outlook offers a more qualified institutional assessment. Its central forecast says AI could boost productivity growth by 0.2 percentage points a year by the medium term, while stressing that the “scale and timing” of the effect are “highly uncertain.” Citing ONS figures, it said 30% of businesses reported using at least one type of AI technology in September 2026, up from 15% two years earlier.

““Confident attribution remains premature.””

— Haley Schlicht, Bank of England Data and Statistics Division

What the Job Data Cannot Prove

The job-ad figures show where hiring advertisements fell, but they do not determine whether AI caused the decline, whether employers filled fewer posts, or whether work shifted to other roles. The UK analysis identifies several simultaneous economic and workplace changes that could affect recruitment. The Australian timeline also complicates attribution: graduate postings began falling in 2023, before widespread AI adoption, and apprenticeship postings fell despite their low AI exposure.

The reported OBR chief’s warning remains unverified in the material reviewed. Nor do the cited measures establish how many graduates have been displaced, whether the declines are temporary, or how AI use changes the number and content of entry-level jobs over time. The OBR itself says it will monitor emerging evidence on productivity and employment.

Evidence to Watch in Hiring

The next useful indicators will be whether vacancies and online adverts continue to fall, and whether the gap between highly exposed and less exposed occupations persists as economic conditions change. Further evidence on actual business adoption and hiring decisions would help distinguish AI-related effects from broader recruitment pressures.

The OBR has said it will closely monitor emerging evidence for its productivity and employment forecasts. For graduates and universities, the practical question raised by the debate is whether training develops judgement alongside the ability to use AI tools: the cited commentary argues that workers will need to recognise weak outputs and improve them. Whether that approach protects entry-level opportunities, or how employers will redesign junior jobs, remains unsettled.

Key Questions

Does the evidence show that AI is causing graduate jobs to disappear?

No. The figures show falling adverts in occupations with greater AI exposure, but the Bank of England analysis says confident attribution is premature. Other economic and workplace factors may have contributed.

Which UK occupations saw the largest advert declines?

In the Bank of England staff analysis, online adverts fell 23% in customer service and 22% in administrative occupations. These are advert declines, not confirmed job losses attributable to AI.

What did the OBR say about AI’s economic effects?

In its October 2026 forecast, the OBR’s central estimate was that AI could boost productivity growth by 0.2 percentage points a year by the medium term. It said the scale and timing of any effect are highly uncertain.

Is the reported warning of very painful job losses confirmed by the OBR?

The source article says The Telegraph reported the warning, but its account could not be independently checked against an OBR or parliamentary record. The OBR’s published forecast presents its assessment of AI’s effects as uncertain.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com

You May Also Like

Audio Interfaces: The Gain and Phantom Power Mistakes Beginners Make

Understanding common gain and phantom power mistakes can save your recordings from distortion and damage—discover how to avoid these pitfalls now.

Why OLED Gaming Looks Incredible but Changes How You Use a Monitor

Understanding why OLED gaming looks incredible also reveals how to optimize your monitor use and prevent issues, ensuring a stunning gaming experience that lasts.

Why Soft Light Beats More Light for Most Creator Setups

Why soft light often outperforms more light in creator setups, offering a natural, flattering look that transforms your visuals—discover how to optimize it further.

How 10 Best Graphics Cards Handle AI, Gaming, And Everyday Use

A buyer-focused look at 10 graphics cards, from current gaming GPUs to older cards for display support and budget upgrades.